After various attempts to analyze various companies which
failed because there were a lot of complications I finally hit on Shree
Cements, I have been hearing a lot about it recently.
It’s been covered in my Corp Val class and my Equity
Research class where I am covering the cement sector. An industry speaker who
come for a guest session in Equity Research was also coincidentally covering
cement sector and he was all praise for how Shree Cements manages itself.
So with all enthusiasm I opened the annual report and I am
really surprised. This is the most transparent annual report I have ever seen.
The report displays the sales in quantity and doesn’t try to hide behind a maze
of numbers for showing revenues. The report shows the quantity of demand and
supply in cement by region. This is very important when analyzing a cement
business because the demand for a brand is very region determined. The high
costs of transportation don’t let cement bags be sold at far off states.
If my valuation comes out higher than the stock value right
now which is highly unlikely because of the high stock price of 7360.30, a lot
of my money is going into this stock. The stock already has the Modi’s bull run
factored in and doesn’t look like there is a major upside now.
Their corporate governance reports and transparency is sure
to get FIIs pumping money into this firm, for FIIs those factors are more
important than the profits. Maybe I should invest in this company.
The bad part of this valuation is I’ll be using the 2013
annual report as the 2014 report is not out yet.
New Projects- A clinker manufacturing unit of 2MTPA is being
set up by June 2014 which I am going to assume will start around that time
because of Shree Cement’s track record. The 4 MTPA cement mills are going to be
commissioned in 2014 so I am going to assume they will be completely
operational from 2015
My first valuation and my value is completely
definitely wrong. My value for a stock of Shree Cement should be Rs 2168 but
the present value is Rs 7500. Obviously they know something that I don’t. I
will get back to correcting it and then updating how I got to the solution.Here is the link to my excel sheet